My Blog

Category: Opinion

  • Latest inflation figures show the RBA was right not to raise rates in April

    Latest inflation figures show the RBA was right not to raise rates in April

    by Greg Jericho in The Guardian

    Greg Jericho

    Chief Economist

    Share

    Originally published in The Guardian on April 27, 2023

    Inflation is falling steadily but hitting low-income households the most.

    The March quarter consumer price index figures showed a 7.0% annual rise, however as Policy Director, Greg Jericho, notes in his Guardian Australia column, the monthly inflation figures that were also released on Wednesday showed annual growth had fallen to 6.3%.

    This fall was down from a peak of 8.4% in December and is the slowest growth since May last year.

    The figures reinforce the belief that the RBA board was right to ignore the views of many economists both within and outside the Reserve Bank. Not only is inflation falling but the biggest drivers of inflation in the March quarter were in areas with prices mostly determined by governments or in highly regulated sectors such as the gas and electricity markets. There was little sense of prices rising due to excess demand, rather the combination of price setting in the public sector and by commercial companies making use of high world prices for resources and ongoing supply issues in the housing market served to drive nearly two-thirds of the total increase in overall inflation the March quarter.

    Increasing interest rates would have done nothing to lower prices in these areas – indeed in the rental market any further rates rises would likely be just used as reason for increasing rents more.

    The Reserve Bank was right to stop raising rates. Should the slowing of inflation shows signs of ending before reaching the RBA’s target of 3% it can always cut rates then. For now, inflation is falling as hoped and attention must be drawn to those suffering the most from the rising prices – notably low-income households and those paying off a HELP debt that is set to be indexed by 7.1% – well above the current levels of wage growth.


    You might also like

  • The Stage 3 tax cuts are bad economics combined with terrible politics. They should be dumped.

    The Stage 3 tax cuts are bad economics combined with terrible politics. They should be dumped.

    by Greg Jericho in The Guardian

    Greg Jericho

    Chief Economist

    Share

    Originally published in The Guardian on April 20, 2023

    The Stage 3 tax cuts were always bad, but with the removal of the low-middle income tax offset, they become a terrible political strategy as well

    During the 2022 election campaign the ALP in a desperate and misguided move to avoid being wedged, agreed to implement the horrendously inequitable Stage 3 tax cuts. But, as Policy Director Greg Jericho writes in his Guardian Australia column agreeing to bad policy in opposition means you own the bad policy in government – except you get no credit for it and all of the blame.

    While the Stage 3 tax cuts have always been wildly expensive and unfair, with around half of the benefit going to the richest 3%, but the removal of the low-middle income tax offset (LMITO) has made them even more unfair and politically foolish for the ALP.

    Because the LMITO was targeted most at those earning between $50,000 and $90,000 and the Stage 3 tax cuts are least targeted towards those people, it means the removal of the $1,500 LMITO for someone on the median income of $65,000 will only be replaced by a $500 tax cut under Stage 3.

    This means the ALP if it continues to implement  Scott Morrison’s tax policy will go to the next election in a position where middle-income earners will be paying more tax than they did in 2022 while people on $200,000 will be $9,075 better off.

    That is a weird strategy for a progressive political party to pursue.

    In reality, the Albanese government will get no credit for implementing the Stage 3 cuts and will get all the blame for leaving around 75% of taxpayers worse compared to the last year of the Morrison government.

    It is time to dump the tax cuts and for the Albanese government to deliver policies that it would be proud to defend. Fairer tax cuts, increase Jobseeker, invest in renewables and other vital infrastructure and improve services.


    You might also like

  • Wealth inequality across generations will only fuel voter disenchantment

    Wealth inequality across generations will only fuel voter disenchantment

    by Greg Jericho in The Guardian

    Greg Jericho

    Chief Economist

    Share

    Originally published in The Guardian on April 13, 2023

    Millennials are not becoming more conservative as they age – and the rigged housing market is just one reason why

    While income inequality is an often discussed topic, wealth inequality is just as pernicious though often less discussed issue. Worse still the inequality of wealth across generations has lasting impacts for people into retirement.

    Policy director Greg Jericho writes in his Guardian Australia column how economic policies of the past few decades has served to provide those with wealth more of it, while depriving younger people of gaining a foothold that previous generations had.

    The issue is most acute with housing. Housing affability is often debated with some suggesting that because of lower interest rate than in the past owning a home is not as difficult as in the past. But the reality is that the size of the mortgage relative to incomes is so much greater than in the past that even with lower interest rates payments account for much more income than they used to. Whereas for those entering the housing market in the 1980s one incomes was often more than enough, now two incomes is a necessity.

    But what is often forgotten is that while interest rates were higher at times in the 1980s and 1990s those rates fell and with them did the payments all the while incomes rose. As a result those who bought homes in the 1980s and 1990s saw their repayments as a share of income fall to very low levels – levels unheard of now.

    And while the arguments about whether housing is more or less affordable can turn on definitions of affordability, the fact is that for the first time fewer than half of people aged 30-34 own their own home.  That’s not through choice, but through the reality of a housing market that is locking out younger people.

    This in turn sees younger generations have less wealth at  their age than did their parents and grandparents.

    It is little surprise that Millennials are not becoming more conservative in their voting as they age in the same way that did Baby Boomers and Gen Xers. The wealth inequality will have ongoing repercussions for political parties who have in the past taken it as given that older voters will vote for them.


    You might also like

    Dutton’s nuclear push will cost renewable jobs

    by Charlie Joyce

    Dutton’s nuclear push will cost renewable jobs As Australia’s federal election campaign has finally begun, opposition leader Peter Dutton’s proposal to spend hundreds of billions in public money to build seven nuclear power plants across the country has been carefully scrutinized. The technological unfeasibility, staggering cost, and scant detail of the Coalition’s nuclear proposal have

    Australia’s Gas Use On The Slide

    by Ketan Joshi

    The Federal Government has released a new report that includes projections of how much gas Australia is set to use over the coming decades. There is no ambiguity in its message: Australia reached peak gas years ago, and it’s all downhill from here:

  • With the impact of rate rises still to come the RBA is wise to pause

    With the impact of rate rises still to come the RBA is wise to pause

    by Greg Jericho in The Guardian

    Greg Jericho

    Chief Economist

    Share

    Originally published in The Guardian on April 6, 2023

    Perhaps as much as a third of the rate rises since April have yet to fully hit the economy

    Since April the Reserve Bank has increased the cash rate by 350 basis points from 0.1% to 3.60% – the fastest and largest increase since the late 1980s. But as policy director Greg Jericho notes in his Guardian Australia column, perhaps as much as a third of the rate rises have yet to fully flow through to the economy.

    While the interest rate of new mortgages has risen the full amount, the average rate of all mortgages has only risen around 209 basis points – with many mortgage holders still yet to have their repayments increase due to the rate rates in December, let alone those in February and March.

    The Reserve Bank noted this in its statement and stressed the need to gather more information before deciding whether to increase rates or keep them steady.

    The most recent GDP figures show the economy overall has slowed and the signs of inflation are that the peak has been reached and much like the USA, it is not heading down. While the path to 3% inflation might take some time there seems little sense of long-term expectations rising and the 350 basis points worth of rises makes it clear the RBA is prepared to act if it believes inflation is accelerating.

    The Centre For Future Work has been calling for a pause in the rates and it welcomes this decision by the RBA.  There is minimal risk from observing the data after 10 successive rate rises. And workers whose wages have not kept pace with inflation will be relieved that the RBA is paying heed to warnings that slowing the economy too fast in an environment where inflation has peaked only increases the risks of sending the economy into a recession


    You might also like

    Dutton’s nuclear push will cost renewable jobs

    by Charlie Joyce

    Dutton’s nuclear push will cost renewable jobs As Australia’s federal election campaign has finally begun, opposition leader Peter Dutton’s proposal to spend hundreds of billions in public money to build seven nuclear power plants across the country has been carefully scrutinized. The technological unfeasibility, staggering cost, and scant detail of the Coalition’s nuclear proposal have

  • Stop the fear, give workers a fair pay rise

    Stop the fear, give workers a fair pay rise

    by Greg Jericho in The Guardian

    Greg Jericho

    Chief Economist

    Share

    Originally published in The Guardian on March 30, 2023

    The whole point of public-sector wage caps is to keep all wages down

    It took roughly one day after the New South Wales election for conservative media groups to begin spreading fear about union power and public sector wage blowouts. But as labour market policy director, Greg Jericho writes in his Guardian Australia column these fears are massively overblown and also ignore the reality of how much workers have lost out over the past few years.

    In NSW public-sector wages grew just 2.5% in 2022, well below private-sector wage growth in that state and massively below inflation which rose 7.6% in that state last year.

    Public-sector wage caps were notionally introduced to get the budget back into surplus, but that was just a fib – once the budget returned to surplus the caps remained. The purpose of the wage caps has always been to drive down private-sector wage growth, a point made abundantly clear by former Treasurer Matt Kean when he told an audience at a Business NSW function that removing the public-sector wage cap would see their companies “competing for labour against the public service who were paying huge wage increases.”

    But the reality is the wage cap not only keeps private-sector wages down it has smashed the living standard of public sector workers whose real wages are now more than 5% lower than they were 2 years ago.

    The fear of wage rises must stop.


    You might also like

    Centre For Future Work to evolve into standalone entity

    The Centre for Future Work was established by the Australia Institute in 2016 to conduct and publish progressive economic research on work, employment, and labour markets. Supported by the Australian Union movement, the centre produced cutting edge research and led the national conversation on economic issues facing working people: including the future of jobs, wages

  • The housing market has cooled, but housing unaffordability remains a long way off

    The housing market has cooled, but housing unaffordability remains a long way off

    by Greg Jericho in The Guardian

    Greg Jericho

    Chief Economist

    Share

    Originally published in The Guardian on March 16, 2023

    House prices are falling but housing unaffordability remains high

    The most recent data on the value of dwelling around Australia reveals the prices in most capital cities have fallen over the past year and are likely to keep doing so for some months. But the data also shows that housing affordability remains a long way from repairing the decades of damage.

    In his Guardian Australia column, policy director, Greg Jericho, notes that the impact of interest rate rises has definitely caused the housing market to come off the boil. In most capital cities median house prices are now below what they were a year ago. Coming as this does off data suggesting wages are not rising as fast as the Reserve Bank feared, and amid the ructions in the USA financial system after the Silicon Valley Bank collapse, the Reserve Bank certainly has enough reason to not raise rates again.

    But while the fall in house prices does help those trying to buy a home, the decrease in affordability is highlighted by the fact that while house prices are mostly below what they were a year ago, they are well above what they were 2 years ago in all capital cities. And those rises have been well above the growth in wages in that time.

    Jericho notes that in Sydney for example, wages and house prices from 2003-2013 largely rose in line but over the past decade house prices have surged above wages. Had prices instead continued to rise in line with wages the median house price in Sydney would now be $863,000 rather than $1,270,000.

    This disconnect is replicated around the country with house prices being some 60% above what they would have been had they risen along with wages. In Hobart the current median house price of $727,000 is some 133% above the price it would have been had they rinse in line with wages in Tasmania of $297,000.

    This disconnect highlights the need for tax reform of the housing market, an increase in supply including increased median density housing, and especially public housing.

    And above all we need wages to no longer be left behind.


    You might also like

    Centre For Future Work to evolve into standalone entity

    The Centre for Future Work was established by the Australia Institute in 2016 to conduct and publish progressive economic research on work, employment, and labour markets. Supported by the Australian Union movement, the centre produced cutting edge research and led the national conversation on economic issues facing working people: including the future of jobs, wages

  • Australian Inflation Reflects a Historic Redistribution from Workers to Bosses

    Australian Inflation Reflects a Historic Redistribution from Workers to Bosses

    by Jim Stanford in The Conversation

    Jim Stanford

    Share

    Originally published in The Conversation on April 7, 2023

    The upsurge of inflation since the COVID-19 lockdowns has not had equal impacts on all Australians. Workers and low-income people have experienced the worst losses: both because their incomes, in most cases, have not kept up with prices, and because they are more dependent on essential goods and services (like shelter, food, and energy) than higher-income households.

    Meanwhile, business profits have expanded strongly through this inflationary episode. Companies haven’t just passed along higher input costs to their customers. Rather, they have taken advantage of the conjuncture of factors related to the pandemic (supply shortages and disruptions, consumer desperation and pent-up demand, and oligopolistic pricing power) to push up prices far higher than needed to cover their own costs.

    The result has been a process of ‘profit-price inflation’: higher profit margins are both a cause and consequence of rapid inflation. Centre for Future Work Director Jim Stanford discusses the distributional impacts of recent inflation in this new commentary for The Conversation: Underlying Australia’s inflation problem is a historic shift of income from workers to corporate profits


    You might also like

  • Superannuation needs an objective and needs to be reviewed

    Superannuation needs an objective and needs to be reviewed

    by Greg Jericho in The Guardian

    Greg Jericho

    Chief Economist

    Share

    Originally published in The Guardian on February 23, 2023

    Superannuation is too important for retirement to be allowed to be a tax dodge scheme for the wealthy. It is time to review the scheme and stop the abuses

    This week the government announced a review to legislate the objective of superannuation. Surprisingly, there is no official objective of superannuation and this has allowed it to be used for purposes that are decidedly not about ensuring a comfortable retirement.

    The review has sparked criticism from the opposition who are using it to suggest the government is coming after your money. But as policy director, Greg Jericho, writes in his Guardian Australia column, for the very rich, superannuation has become less about retirement and more about dodging tax.

    Because super contributions are taxed at 15% the biggest benefit goes to those who are on the highest marginal income tax rate. As a result, those with the highest incomes contribute much more of their own money to superannuation than do those on lower incomes. Those earning over $150,000 make up 7% of individuals, 27% of total income, but 32% of total personal superannuation contributions. Also because there is no limit on the size of superannuation balances that can access this tax concession it means those with the very largest superannuation balances continue to get the advantage of a tax concession that has long past any sense of assisting a comfortable retirement.

    These tax concessions are now extremely costly – costing the government almost as much as the aged pension – and moreover so slanted are the benefits to the wealthy that the richest 20 per cent cost the government more tax concessions than it would pay them the full aged pension.

    Clearly, the system is not working as it should. It is not about self-funding retirement but funding retirement by avoiding tax.

    The Treasurer has suggested putting a cap on the size of superannuation balances – somewhere around $3m. Such a size would only affect less than 1.5% of all individuals aged 55-69. But clearly needs to be done because those 1.5% hold 14% of all superannuation balances of people in that age.

    Superannuation is important and vital for the retirement of many Australians. But it should not be used just to avoid paying tax – the cost of that lost revenue is denying assistance to those who actually need help once they stop work.


    You might also like

    Centre For Future Work to evolve into standalone entity

    The Centre for Future Work was established by the Australia Institute in 2016 to conduct and publish progressive economic research on work, employment, and labour markets. Supported by the Australian Union movement, the centre produced cutting edge research and led the national conversation on economic issues facing working people: including the future of jobs, wages

  • With interest rates set to rise another 3 times, no wonder consumers are feeling grim

    With interest rates set to rise another 3 times, no wonder consumers are feeling grim

    by Greg Jericho in The Guardian

    Greg Jericho

    Chief Economist

    Share

    Originally published in The Guardian on February 16, 2023

    The Reserve Bank now forecasts real household incomes will take longer to recover than they did during the 1990s recession and is also projecting economic growth at historical lows. Australian consumers are right to feel worried about the future.

    Right now Australian consumers have less confidence than they did in April 2020 when the entire world was locked down and the pandemic was raging without any prospect of a vaccine.

    That might suggest that Australians are overly pessimistic, especially given unemployment is at generational lows of 3.5%, but when you look at the statements of the Reserve Bank and its projections for the next 2 years, it is little wonder Australians are worried.

    Last week the RBA not only lifted the cash rate for the 9th straight time, it signalled that there would be a plural number of rises to come. In response, the market now anticipates at least three more rate rises, with a slight chance of 4 more. That would be easily the fastest and largest raising of interest rates since the late 1980s. And Australians are well aware of what occurred after the 1980s rate rises.

    Indeed even the Reserve Bank is anticipating a sharp slowing of the economy. While not suggesting a recession is imminent, in its latest Statement on Monetary Policy the RBA forecast 2 straight years of GDP growth of less than 1.8%. That would equal the record length of less than 2% growth during the 1990s recession. In reality, anytime Australia’s economy has grown by less than 2% for just one year there has been either a recession or near recession conditions such as during the GFC.

    Australians are right to be wary especially as their standard of living has suffered a sharp decline in the past year as incomes fail to keep up with inflation.

    The Reserve Bank of course does need to be concerned about inflation but given the expectations of recessions of slight contractions in the UK, USA and Europe the risk of a recession should be weighed much higher than they currently are.


    You might also like

  • The Reserve Bank is betting that monetary policy is not powerful

    The Reserve Bank is betting that monetary policy is not powerful

    by Greg Jericho in The Guardian

    Greg Jericho

    Chief Economist

    Share

    Originally published in The Guardian on February 9, 2023

    The signs are already evident that household consumption is falling despite most mortgage holders yet to feel the full effects of the rate rises. The Reserve Bank however believes more pain is needed.

    On Tuesday the Reserve Bank lifted the cash rate to 3.35%, making for a total increase of 325 basis points since May last year. That rise is the fastest since the rises prior to the 1990s recession. And yet, as policy director Greg Jericho, notes in his Guardian Australia column, the Reserve Bank still think more is needed.

    The Governor’s statement concluded that “the Board expects that further increases in interest rates will be needed over the months ahead”. The use of the plural “increases” was a change from the language used in December. This is despite the bank and most economists acknowledging that inflation peaked in December and that global inflation is now falling.

    The RBA acknowledges that the full impact of the rate rises has yet to flow through, and how remains wedded to the policy that the economy is running too hot, despite wage growth likely still in the low 3% range. Most households have yet to feel the impact of around a third of the total amount of the rate rises thus far. With more rate rises forecast to come, that suggests a further increase of around $400 a month in mortgage repayments on a $500,000 loan even before any more rate rises occur. That would suggest a 45% increase in mortgage repayments since April.

    This drastic raising in rates will serve to slow an already slowing economy. The December quarter retail trade figures showed that retail turnover volume was down for the fourth straight quarter, and forecasts for GDP growth estimate very weak growth for two years.

    That the Reserve Bank continue to hike rates without pause suggests a lack of faith in its biggest weapon to reduce inflation, and also that it can finesse rate rises and economic growth. There is no need to keep hurting households without relief or pause – especially given so much of the rate rises remain yet to be felt.


    You might also like

    Centre For Future Work to evolve into standalone entity

    The Centre for Future Work was established by the Australia Institute in 2016 to conduct and publish progressive economic research on work, employment, and labour markets. Supported by the Australian Union movement, the centre produced cutting edge research and led the national conversation on economic issues facing working people: including the future of jobs, wages